Black Friday has a sneaky way of turning “let’s run a big sale” into “why did we make so little money?” The problem usually isn’t the sale itself. It’s discounting the wrong products. With Black Friday eight days away, here’s a simple way to decide which SKUs deserve a discount and which ones don’t.
What Shoppers Will Expect
Adobe forecasts discounts of up to 30% off list price during Cyber Week. That’s a ceiling across the season, not an average, and it varies a lot by category:
- Electronics: up to 30%
- Toys: up to 29%
- TVs, computers, and apparel: up to 23%
- Sporting goods: up to 19%
- Appliances and furniture: up to 18%
Adobe also expects Cyber Week to bring in $47.5 billion in online sales, with Black Friday alone at $12.9 billion, up 9.2%. So demand is real, and shoppers will compare prices. But matching the biggest number you see online is a trap.
Deeper Isn’t Always Better
Klaviyo’s 2024 data, as summarized by Eightx, found that discounts in the 10–15% and 20–25% ranges converted best, and that deeper cuts didn’t convert better. The same analysis found only 21.8% of new Black Friday and Cyber Monday customers made a repeat purchase. Treat these as directional, since they come from email- and SMS-driven online brands, but the lesson is clear: a bigger discount doesn’t guarantee a bigger win.
Sort Every SKU Into Three Buckets
Pull up your catalog and give each product one of these labels.
Bucket 1: Discount it. These are products with a healthy margin even after the discount, plenty of stock, and a reason to move: slow sellers, aging inventory, or items that bring in new customers. Offering a deal here frees up cash and storage space.
Bucket 2: Protect it. These are your best sellers. They’re already selling well, so a deep cut mostly gives away margin on sales you’d have made anyway. Try a small discount, a bundle, or a free gift instead.
Bucket 3: Leave it alone. Thin-margin items, anything with limited stock, and products with high return rates. A sale on a product you can’t profitably restock only creates a bigger problem in December.
Do the Math Before You Set the Price
For each product you plan to discount, work out what’s left after the sale price minus product cost, marketplace fees, shipping, ad spend, and expected returns. If that number is too small to cover your overhead, the discount is too deep. Write down a maximum discount for each SKU and stick to it, even when a competitor goes lower.
This is where Ecommerce Data Analytics earns its keep. Looking at margin by product, not by store, shows you which SKUs can afford a sale and which can’t.
Try Value Instead of Price Cuts
Not every offer has to be a markdown. Bundles, buy-two-get-one deals, free shipping thresholds, and free gifts raise the average order without lowering your price on every item. They also keep your pricing consistent across channels, which matters when shoppers compare you on three tabs at once.
Match the Offer to the Right Day
Adobe expects the deepest discounts to land on different days by category:
- Cyber Monday: electronics and computers
- Black Friday: TVs, toys, apparel, appliances, and furniture
- Thanksgiving Day: sporting goods
If you sell in one of these categories, plan your biggest offer for its peak day, rather than running the same deal all week.
Plan Your Next Move Too
A sale is only the first half of the story. Decide now how you’ll follow up with new customers, such as an email or a reorder reminder, because repeat buyers are where the long-term profit is. Strong Ecommerce Revenue Optimization looks at what a customer is worth over months, not just on the day of the sale.
Sellers who think like a Global Ecommerce Accelerator also review results quickly. Check sales, margin, and returns by SKU every day of the sale, and pause anything that’s losing money. A Global Ecommerce Accelerator mindset means treating promotion as a series of small decisions, not one big bet. If you do only one thing today, list your top twenty SKUs, give each a maximum discount, and mark the ones you won’t discount at all. A Global Ecommerce Accelerator would call that the minimum prep for any big sale. It keeps Black Friday from becoming a margin problem, and it gives your Ecommerce Data Analytics something concrete to track. Ecommerce Revenue Optimization starts with that list.
Sources
- Adobe forecast: $275.1B season, Cyber Week $47.5B, Black Friday $12.9B (up 9.2%), discounts up to 30% in Cyber Week, category discount levels, and the deepest-discount day by category: Adobe via Business Wire (Sept 28, 2026)
- Klaviyo’s best-converting discount bands (10–15% and 20–25%), deeper cuts not converting better, and only 21.8% of new BFCM customers buying again: Eightx, BFCM discount depth benchmarks